Can a retaining wall be a dividing fence?

Posted on January 22nd, 2019

Share on LinkedInTweet about this on TwitterEmail this to someoneShare on Google+Print this page

Can a Retaining Wall be a Dividing Fence?Nham & anor v Hayes & anor [2018] NSWCATCD 17

NCAT looked at several issues in this Dividing Fences application, the most interesting one involved retaining walls.

In short, the applicants had served a Fencing Notice under section 11 of the Dividing Fences Act 1991 (NSW) (the Act), which was not agreed to by the neighbours. At the same time the respondents began an action in the Supreme Court of New South Wales substantially in negligence and trespass.

The key issue for the Tribunal was whether the orders sought in relation to a new/replacement retaining wall fell within the definition of fencing work as defined by the Act. Generally, the definition of fencing work under the Act excludes “retaining walls“, except where they are a “…foundation or support necessary for the support and maintenance of the fence” (paragraph (c) of the definition of “fence”).

The Tribunal considered whether the primary purpose of the retaining wall was: 1) to retain soil; or, 2) as a footing/support for the dividing fence. It concluded that the Applicant must bring evidence about whether the retaining wall work falls within paragraph (c). It is not enough to just state what work is proposed. Without evidence the Tribunal could not infer the retaining wall fell within paragraph (c). The application was dismissed.

The Tribunal did not expressly state what evidence would be sufficient, it is likely a suitably qualified expert would be required to show the primary purpose falls within paragraph (c).

David Collins, Senior Solicitor at Mullane & Lindsay Solicitors, NewcastleDavid Collins is a Senior Solicitor at Mullane & Lindsay Solicitors and practises extensively in Commercial dispute resolution and litigationIf you require any assistance in these areas please contact David Collins to arrange a consultation or contact our Newcastle or Sydney office. 

Share on LinkedInTweet about this on TwitterEmail this to someoneShare on Google+Print this page